Kaminey – References and Metaphors


References in Kaminey –

Apart from belonging mostly in the genre of films like Pulp Fiction, Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels, and Manmohan Desai film films which Vishal Bhardwaj openly says he admires, I found two other films that may have influenced Kaminey –

1. PARASH PATHAR(1958) - The scene in Kaminey towards the end of the film when the little boy trades chocolate with Amole Gupte for keeping quiet is a reference to Parash Pathar directed by Satyajit Ray.

2. OLDBOY(2003) – In the scene where Charlie recalls how his Dad died, we see Charlie as a grown up child as well as a kid in the flashback. Vishal Bhardwaj uses that brilliantly. We see young Charlie bring the money to get his father out of the prison. But it’s too late and Guddu throws the money back to Charlie. The young Charlie is replaced by Shahid Kapur in the scene and the scene becomes a metaphor that Charlie even after growing up feels the pain he felt when he was young and holds himself responsible for his father’s death. The switch of young Charlie to Shahid Kapur in the flashback itself is a reference to Oldboy when O Daesu goes back to his school to remember the incident that happened. We see the switching between young O Daesu and the older one when he tries to recall the incident.

Metaphors in Kaminey –

1. The shifting in railway tracks – After the death of his father, Charlie changes his track and goes into the bad lane. He comes back on the right track after the confrontation with his brother towards the end. And both the scenes which made him first go to the wrong track in life and come back to the right lane happen near the railway tacks. So the shifting in railway tracks can be related to Charlie’s life.

2. Mikhail when he first appears in the film wears a dress and shades that is very similar to the ones that are used to represent AIDS disease in the Fatak song. Is Vishal Bhardwaj trying to say that association with people like Mikhail is as dangerous as the AIDS disease?


Posted by Sarah • Kaminey15 comments




1. essy | October 18 2009 - 17:26


Soo if i was still in school, i could have totally used this movie as an example for my english essays and would probably would have aced it =D


2. | October 19 2009 - 00:39


yaa this movie is very gud & have used all the prop very well


3. | October 19 2009 - 01:39


u'r verry well great star all the best 4 u ya


4. Ramisa | October 19 2009 - 03:38


Well ya Kaminey rocks n Shahid as wellyelove
Hey Shahid...ur the future superstar of bollywood
I mean..ur already a superstar n I meant ull be like SRK or Big B
maybe better than them!!!Inshallahsmilesmile
All the veryyyyyyy best Shahid
may Allah always bless u
love yalove
mmmmmuuuuuuuuaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhlove:y
e:


5. Ramisa | October 19 2009 - 04:14


Hey Sarah or Reema can u tell me how can I upload pics on SO.net gallery?
anyone can tell me
n Im already registered
plz I need ur help
thanks,Ramisa


6. sara k | October 19 2009 - 20:01


SHAHID SHOULD MAKE HIS PRESENCE FEEL BY BEING AT EVERY PARTY EVERY HAPPENING. OUT OF SIGHT IS OUT OF MIND. LEARN BIZ TRICKS U FOOL. UR FANS NEED TO SEE U AND U ARE NO WHERE. GET SOME PR LEASSONS. BE THERE MAN. STOP HIDING. GLAMOUR IS AL ABOUT BEING PRESENT EVERYWHERE NOT HYBERNATION.


7. Ramisa | October 21 2009 - 03:13


Hey sara k,I guess Shahid is now shooting in NY for his next film with Anushka n if u wanna say this things...I guess then u should say it properly
I mean maybe I dont have a right to say anything to u,but if ur a true Shahid fan then u shouldnt use words like 'fool'.
ya we need to see him more but its totally his choice where he'll go or not.
I thing thats all..


8. essy | October 21 2009 - 05:48


If your a true fan, he's sort of always ..everywhere anyway? He's always on TV promoting movies and such and he's got more lined up! Hes not in hybernation. and if you do think that he's still "not showing himself" more..well, he doesnt HAVE to be in the public eye like other uptight celebs to show himself off.

If he doesnt want people to make a big deal out of his life, thats his choice. You can't ask him to entertain you 24/7.

Totally agree with you, Ramisa


9. Ramisa | October 21 2009 - 08:34


Hey thanks essy for agreeing with me n yes,I also agree with u that we cant ask him to entertain us all the time=)


10. | October 22 2009 - 05:43


hey ramisa n essy i totally agree wid u guys... n to u sara i wanna say dat we all want 2 see him more bt he is busy shooting in NY n he cant be there for us all da time so u shouldn't be sayin him a 'fool'!!evilfuckdummies


11. | October 22 2009 - 08:11


u son of a beach u r not real 1.idiut fool. i m your big fan but ithink u r not real. sorry!
if ur the real plz reply on my id jurk fool ???


12. Ramisa | October 23 2009 - 03:23


Hey who the hell r u saying this things to???
Shahid?????????
oh plzz....then stop this bloody nonsenseidiots


13. Ramisa | October 23 2009 - 03:26


Btw...do u know the spelling of b**ch
or ur tryin to say...sea beach
LOLlollollol


14. priyamadhavi | October 23 2009 - 12:25


kaminey and shahid rocks all the way ILY lots


15. | October 23 2009 - 22:15


dil bole hadippa and kaminey shahid rockzz

Leave a comment



what suck idiots lol neo ass sleep gm yaya realy cheef ye whatsup ganjubars evil love yep ohbaby fff smile yousuckers fuckdummies 


Type 1234 in the box:



[b]Bold[/b] [i]Italic[/i] [u]Underline[/u] [del]Linethrough[/del] [q]Quote[/q]